Map Rating\Review Thread

This thread can be used to post a Mapshot of a Map you made for your Hack of any GB(A)/C game, it can be Red, Gold, Ruby, Fire-Red, etc.
The Users then can rate your Maps on a scale from 1 (Being Worst) to 10 (Being Best), and give additional information on what can be improved or added.

All of the FS Rules still apply here.

- No Requests.
Do not request a map to be made, this only Rating
and Reveiws.

- No Stealing
Dont put a map that is not yours.

- Only Maps and Ratings/Reviws.
You are only allowed to post Maps you want to have rated/reviewd, or more information for Maps that you
have posted. Do not ask questions about Maps, instead, send a PM to the Map-Maker or a Moderator.

When posting a mapshot

- Map Name:

- The Rom You used:

- Any comments about your map:

- What Type of replie do you want : review, rate,
or anyone one out of the two.

And remember, the mapshot can only be 400x400 pixel.
If bigger please put in a spoiler.

When Rating a mapshot

Rated Map: Either Link or Quote the post of the Map you want to rate.
That way everyone will know what map you are talking about.

Rating: Your rating of a Map on a scale from 1 to 10.

Reason: The reason for your rating.

Suggestions: Suggestions for what to add/change/improve on a Map.

When Revewing a mapshot

Reviewed Map: Either Link or Quote the post of the Map you want to review.
That way everyone will know what map you are talking about.

Review: Your review~

Suggestions: Suggestions for what to add/change/improve on a Map.

If you have any questions, feel free to PM any of the ROM Hacking moderators.




By Naruto Actor
If a Admin Rates your map 10/10 I will send you 100 Points
any other rating dose not earn you points.

I notice on PC some people got mad when I rated there map insted of review and some didnt care so when you post a map I think this should be added
When posting a mapshot

- Map Name:

- The Rom You used:

- Any comments about your map:

-What Type of replie do you want : revew rate or dont care

Petalburg City

Fire red

Re-creation of Hoenn maps with FR

Review wanted.

Its okay.

Suggestions: too many bushes.
- Add flowers
- Some of the little trees wold help out the map.

My rating:
7.8 total
Goodmap

Well, I was gonna add to it, but that is pretty much exact to the dot so adding those trees would change it and I'm not sure if the guy in charge of the hack this is for would want it changed.
The only thing changed is the path leading to the middle house and I only put it there as there was nothing like that pallett on the FR Tilesets.

ahh you guys are not geting the Idea thats a rate a rate is when You give it a score a a few sentences why you gave it that and how can it improve a reveiw is breaking down all its flaws with a paragrah for each now as reviews are nice you have a better chance of getting a rate so chose wisely

Shugo wrote:Petalburg City

Fire red

Re-creation of Hoenn maps with FR

Review wanted.

Good map, just make the PokeCenters and PokeMarts fire-red size and maybe not have the bush's next to each other, tree's could possibly work...7/10

I tried to make it exact, the hedges are touching in R/S/E and the hack this is for remakes all reigons in FR/LG Tilesets.
Pokecenters and marts are smaller in R/S/E so you know, just made 'em like that, but now the guy in charge wants them normal size so they'll normal on my next map for this project.

oh and I just notice some tile erros fix that

Same here, behind the poke mart

that and inside the routes you dont have the turing tile

Ok, apparently that hack has been scraped now but here are 2 other maps I made whilst working on the hack;


For some reason they never come out full size but it'd work on a rom.

10/10 if your going for nintendo style

Yeah actually it' meant to be Hoenn maps in FR tiles so I tried to make it as good as possible.
Random maps are usually a lot more original than this.

Map Name: SLEFIX TOWN
Rom used: Ruby
comments about your map: A map from my new hack. Thanks to deviation for the base.
What Type of reply do you want: Rating and Reveiw

Spoiler: